Review: TipTop Kitchen and Cocktails

I’ll be the first to admit that I don’t get downtown nearly as often as I should to dine. As a resident of Columbus’ suburbs, I find it a bit daunting to navigate the downtown streets with its one way streets and parking meters, trying to find parking. So with the goal of forcing myself to get downtown more, I bought a bunch of discounted dining certificates to restaurants all over Columbus, including downtown.

One of the places I bought certificates for was TipTop Kitchen and Cocktails on Gay Street, near Third. I had only been in the TipTop once before, a year prior, for drinks. I had meant to go back, really I had. But by the time I got a hankering to go, it was either the middle of the lunch rush or during dinner time, and I just didn’t feel up to dealing with the logistical issues.

The idea to go to TipTop dawned on my husband and I in mid-afternoon, well after the lunch rush, but way before parking would become an issue. So we headed downtown and promptly found a metered space about half a block away from the restaurant.

It was a beautiful day, clear and in the 70’s, so we decided to eat outside on the cute little patio they’ve got set up there. I think everyone else had the same idea, as no one was inside – everybody was just outside enjoying the cool breeze and probably one of the last nice days we’ll have for a while.

Our waitress was quick, charming and not shy about making suggestions when my husband asked. One of the nice touches I noticed right off the bat was the huge size of the beverages/water that she brought out – no asking for constant refills, that’s for sure!

For an appetizer, we decided on a basket of sweet potato fries ($5), which are served with spicy mayo. These were so absolutely addictive, that I’ll go back if for nothing else but these. Subtle sweet flavor in a nice crispy fry, and they had my heart with the seasoned salt (I’m a sucker for fries sprinkled with seasoned salt). The spicy mayo that they pair it with goes perfectly – my only complaint is that I wish they had just a bit more mayo with it, because even conserving the mayo, I ran out before the basket was gone. Just filling the little Solo cup to the top would make all the difference in the world.

Sweet Potato Fries with Spicy Mayo

We shared a crock of Spicy Vegetarian Corn Chowder ($5), which had a nice kick to the creamy soup that was loaded with huge chunks of potato and other vegetables. I’m a die-hard omnivore, and let me tell you, I didn’t miss the meat at all.

Vegetarian Corn Chowder

I had originally ordered the Tilapia ($10), which is drizzled in adobo sauce and served with chipotle risotto and steamed veggies, for myself. My husband took a couple of bites and insisted that I trade entrees with him right then and there. He was so smitten with the risotto, and the combination of the fish and the risotto, that he wanted it for himself. His entree-lust was so great that he threatened to order a portion of this to-go if I didn’t trade.

The fish was excellent. Nicely sauteed, with the right amount of browning. The risotto? Pretty freaking amazing. I love a good risotto, and I fell in love with this at first bite. Who knew you could find good risotto in a comfort food joint in the middle of downtown?

Tilapia with Chipotle Risotto

So what did I get in trade for my tilapia and risotto? What did my husband pass up for what was behind door #2? A really freaking good Ohio Style Monte Cristo Sandwich ($10), which he had ordered with potato salad on the side because the eggplant fries we wanted haven’t been available for the past few weeks ::sniff:: The sandwich was a properly made Monte Cristo, unlike the last few I’ve had, which were just plain old sandwiches dipped in a disgustingly thick batter. No, this was beautiful – the only thing battered on this puppy was the bread, as it should be. And in between those battered bread slices was some nicely shaved turkey, ham, swiss and a rockin’ honey mustard sauce. With just a little Smuckers strawberry jam spread on it, I didn’t regret my trade at all.

The potato salad was one of the best I’ve had in a restaurant, because it reminded me of mine – not sweet, very creamy, nice big chunks of potato, and extremely flavorful.


We really wanted to try dessert, but they didn’t have any available, as they had run out over the weekend. If there is any fault to be found with my meal at all, it was the unavailability of certain items, which is a minor logistical issue that is easily overlooked unless it becomes a chronic problem.

So color us pleasantly surprised. We had an idea that it would be good, but we didn’t know that it would be *that* good. So parking issues be damned, I’ll definitely be back.

If you’d like to go: TipTop Kitchen and Cocktails, 73 E. Gay St, Columbus, 614.221.8300

Tip Top on Urbanspoon

8 thoughts on “Review: TipTop Kitchen and Cocktails

  1. Tim Lessner


    I’m so glad you liked the food!
    Thank you for the kind words.

    We’ll get a little tighter about filling the spicy mayo cups to the brim. It seems to be a hit and you’re definitely not the first to want more! We’ll get on it I promise!

    I’m glad you made it into downtown. I know the parking and roads and everything are often a deterrent. Helpful hint: come on a Sunday. No one is at work and parking is plentiful 😉

    Also, we plan to make a few changes for the winter menu…the country fried steak is coming back as well as some new winter comfort! Look for it about mid November.

    Thanks again for checking us out! Your review made our day!

    Very Best,

    Tim Lessner

  2. Amanda

    Hi there! I love your blog – I regularly read your posts and consistently print out the recipes, so thanks!

    I just had to reply to this post about the TipTop… We absolutely LOVE this place and I feel obliged to recommend the pot roast! Very rarely do you find a restaurant with good pot roast (food that takes all day to slow-cook doesn’t usually taste so great made-to-order) and the pot roast at the TipTop is FANTASTIC! Shoot, you should try everything on the menu… We haven’t had a bad dish yet! (The meatloaf springs to mind here.)

    Overall, the drink selection is creative AND tasty, the food is beyond wonderful, and if you ride a bike in (I think you need to show your helmet) there’s some sort of deal on PBR.

    *I can’t wait to see the new menu additions in November!!


  3. Pingback: The Betty Blog » Blog Archive » Review: TipTop Kitchen and Cocktails

  4. Becka

    You need to try the Blue Ribbon Pot Roast. Or the pot roast sandwich. Dear God, they are good- it's so hard living so close to them, all we ever want to do is eat pot roast sandwiches….

Comments are closed.