Manhattan Sandwich

Author: swampkitty05  //  Category: Copycat, Food Porn, North Market, Recipes

One of my guilty pleasures lately has been the Manhattan Sandwich at Barry’s New York Deli at the North Market. The first time I ordered it I wouldn’t think the combination of flavors would work, but surprisingly they do.

Manhattan Sandwich

So I’ve been giving my panini press here at home a workout lately – and this one is quite simple. Spread Russian dressing on both slices of rye bread (I usually use a marble rye), and then layer smoked cheddar and corned beef. Grill until browned, and then open it up and put some cole slaw in the middle. A million kinds of awesome.

So tell me, what are your favorite panini sandwiches to make? What combination of flavors really does it for you?

5 Responses to “Manhattan Sandwich”

  1. Jean Collier Says:

    Pesto, sundried tomatoes (actually I use roma tomatoes that I oven dried) and fresh mozzarella…heaven!

  2. Regina Says:

    Along the lines of your panini, I like a good Turkey Reuben with Coleslaw in place of the kraut. I first saw the use of slaw on a sandwich when I lived in Philly, pure genius. My husband is a fan of the turkey/apple/brie combination. We live in Cleveland now and the biggest problem is finding quality bread for paninis…I wish we had a Cosi up here because I think their flatbread is perfect for making paninis.

    Love your blog…we're former Buckeyes and reading about your culinary adventures in Columbus makes us miss it even more!

  3. Susan Says:

    Swiss cheese–sauted mushrooms on sourdough..Yum!!

  4. Maggie Says:

    That sandwich looks great, like a Reuben with coleslaw in place of sauerkraut. It's not a panini but I'm really craving a sandwich I used to get in college it had falafel, cheddar, avocado, ranch dressing and alfalfa sprouts on grilled rye bread. It was the best thing!

  5. hungrywoolf Says:

    have you tried the old fashioned at Details yet? I think you would enjoy it. Thanks for your comment. I definitely like to be busy!

Leave a Reply